Why Scientific Support for Alcohol’s Health Benefits Is Fading

Nonetheless, self-reports of motives for drinking alcohol provide insight into people’s psychological state and have empirically been related to consumption levels (Cahalan et al., 1969; Cooper et al., 1988; Farber et al., 1980). Most authors have focused on general samples of the adult population or college students, rather than alcoholics or identified problem drinkers. The majority of these studies have focused on the factor structure of individuals’ motives for drinking, as well as determining if some types of motives are more strongly related than others to heavy alcohol consumption. If someone drinks alcohol primarily to reduce stress, then this individual is most likely to drink under times of stress; it is at these times that there is fit between the individual’s personal motives and life situation. If someone else drinks alcohol primarily in order to socialize, then this individual is most likely to drink during periods of social activity; it is at these times that there is fit between the individual’s personal motives and life circumstances.

It’s prompting a reevaluation of alcohol’s place in society and challenging long-held assumptions about its role in a healthy lifestyle. For five decades, the institute has studied how alcohol affects our health, bringing greater awareness to alcohol-related health issues and providing better options for diagnosis and treatment. While the idea of abstaining completely may feel daunting, there’s a growing cultural shift toward mindful drinking, or not drinking. Younger generations are drinking less and non-alcoholic beverages are becoming more popular. Ultimately, clinicians like Stafford and Humphreys said they hope people who decide to drink alcohol do it consciously, armed with knowledge about its risks. Surgeon General’s Advisory reported that among 100 women who have less than one drink per week, about 17 will develop an alcohol-related cancer.

Stanford Medicine research

In a normal population of drinkers, quantity and frequency of alcohol consumption vary depending on an individual’s situation. Consequently, there is a need to examine both reasons for drinking alcohol, and the extent to which current circumstances fit these reasons, in order to explain current levels of alcohol consumption. A cross-sectional study of adults aged 16 and over, recruited via the February 2023 and April 2023 waves of the Alcohol Toolkit Study.41 This is a monthly telephone survey of adults residing in Great Britain, capturing respondents’ alcohol drinking behaviour. In these two waves only, five additional questions capturing respondents’ alcohol drinking motives were included.

  • Interviews were conducted either online or by telephone with a live interviewer.
  • The findings were widely publicized and promoted by the alcohol industry, and they gained traction in the medical community.
  • These findings demonstrate the importance of simultaneously considering personal motives for drinking alcohol and the extent to which individuals’ life circumstances correspond to these motives for drinking.
  • “Alcohol-related harms are increasing at multiple levels—from emergency department visits and hospitalizations to deaths,” Dr. Koob says.
  • We now understand how alcohol affects the brain and why it causes symptoms of AUD.

Increasing Emergency Department Patient Navigation And Buprenorphine Use: A Model For Low-Barrier Treatment

Chen’s research has shown how alcohol affects people of East Asian descent who have a genetic variation, ALDH2, which interferes with their ability to metabolize acetaldehyde. These people — about 8% of the world’s population — often experience facial flushing and a rapid heartbeat after just one drink. The health risks of alcohol develop because ethanol, the type of alcohol found in beverages, metabolizes into a compound called acetaldehyde, which damages DNA and other cellular components. When acetaldehyde builds up in the body, it can damage cells throughout the digestive system and beyond. Here are the questions used for this analysis, the topline and the survey methodology.

“We want everyone from pharmacists and nurses to addiction medicine specialists to know more about alcohol and addiction.” Other breakthroughs have been made in screening and intervention, and in the medications available for treatment. All of this has led to a better understanding of how the body changes when one misuses alcohol and the proactive actions we can take to prevent alcohol misuse.

Understanding the gut-brain connection

Routine drinkers and those who drink monthly are somewhat more likely than those who drink only a few times a year or never to have heard of these findings. Perceived stress was measured using a modified version of Pearlin and Schooler’s (1978) measure of role overload. This is a chronic stressor which is applicable to people from a wide range of circumstances. Research suggests that chronic and daily stressors may have a larger impact on health and well-being than do major life events (DeLongis, Folkman, & Lazarus, 1988). Four items assessed the extent to which study participants currently felt that they did not have enough time, had too much work to do, worked too many hours, and that others expected too much of them. (Work was defined as all types of work which people do, not just paid employment.) Responses were made on 5-point Likert scales with response options ranging from “strongly disagree” to “strongly agree.” The Cronbach alpha was .80.

Young people and nicotine: 5 things to know

“So the answer to the question of why alcoholics drink is probably that there is no single answer; this will probably have implications for how we diagnose and treat alcoholism.” This evolving perspective challenges us to reconsider our drinking habits and societal norms around alcohol. It also underscores the importance of staying informed about the latest health research and being open to changing our behaviors based on new scientific evidence. This changing landscape has significant implications for public health policy, healthcare practices, and individual decision-making.

An interactional model of alcohol consumption

  • Other goals include understanding recovery and what treatments work best for people and why.
  • Nonetheless, self-reports of motives for drinking alcohol provide insight into people’s psychological state and have empirically been related to consumption levels (Cahalan et al., 1969; Cooper et al., 1988; Farber et al., 1980).
  • Thirty-three percent of study participants resided in a city, 14% lived in a suburb, 18% lived in a town, and 35% lived in a rural area.
  • We study drinking and other drug use and how these and other factors such as gender, race/ethnicity, sexual identity, socioeconomic disparities, and environmental differences affect health.

This interactional approach was examined in a general population survey of adult drinkers. It was hypothesized that there would be an interaction between reasons for drinking and environmental circumstances. More specifically, it was hypothesized that, for individuals who reported drinking alcohol to cope with stress, alcohol consumption would be higher if levels of stress were high rather than low. In a similar manner, it was hypothesized that for individuals who reported drinking alcohol for social reasons, alcohol consumption would be higher if social network members’ drinking levels were high rather than low.

But they think the public should be made more aware of those risks, which include an increased risk of cancer from drinking moderate amounts of alcohol. The changing narrative around alcohol also highlights the importance of ongoing, unbiased research in public health. It serves as a reminder that scientific understanding evolves, and we must be willing to update our beliefs and behaviors in light of new evidence. As scientific support for alcohol’s health benefits continues to fade, it’s clear that we need to reassess our relationship with alcohol both individually and as a society. This doesn’t necessarily mean that everyone needs to abstain completely, but it does suggest that we should be more mindful of our consumption and its potential long-term effects. In recent years, why alcoholics drink research insights there has been a significant shift in the scientific community’s stance on alcohol consumption.

Women are more susceptible to some of the negative effects that alcohol has on the body, from liver disease to certain cancers. Further, more older adults are binge drinking and this places them at greater risk of alcohol-medication interactions, falls, and health problems related to alcohol misuse. Many of the items in both of the reasons for drinking scales were selected from previous research. The “cheer” and “forget” items from the coping scale and the “sociable,” “people they knew,” and “celebrate” items from the sociability scale were similar to items used by Cahalan et al. (1969) and Farber et al. (1980).

For example, Brown (1985) found that college students’ problematic drinking was linked to tension-reduction expectancies, while frequent drinking was linked to social and physical-pleasure expectancies. Christiansen, Smith, Roehling, and Goldman (1989) found that alcohol expectancies in early adolescence predicted problem drinking 1 year later. There is also variation in whether participants have been asked about their expectancies for people, in general, or for themselves, personally. Despite the conceptual overlap between expectancies and reasons for drinking, these literatures are largely separate, and few authors measure both in a single study.

Sociodemographic variables

Interviews were conducted between April and July 2022, with participants reflecting on their alcohol use over the previous year. A majority of drinkers (57%) think their own alcohol use does not increase their risk of serious physical health problems. Still, 43% say their drinking does increase their risk of health problems either a lot or a little.

Comentários

Deixe um comentário

O seu endereço de e-mail não será publicado. Campos obrigatórios são marcados com *

Este site utiliza o Akismet para reduzir spam. Saiba como seus dados em comentários são processados.